Michigan’s Governor Has Power to Grant Reprieves, Commutations, and Pardons
Michigan does not have a compassionate release law; however, Executive Clemency is a similar process. A medically frail individual might qualify for emergency relief.
Emergency Petition for Commutation of Sentence or Executive Clemency
The Governor’s executive clemency authority is derived from Section 14 of Article V of the Michigan Constitution of 1963, which states that the Governor shall have the power to grant reprieves, commutations, and pardons. Under this section of Michigan’s constitution, the Governor has the power to grant a Petition for Commutation of Sentence.
A commutation is the reduction of an individual’s sentence so that the Michigan Parole Board is given the authority to immediately determine an individual’s parole eligibility instead of waiting until after they’ve served their minimum sentence. A commutation does not nullify the underlying convictions.
Commutation is Not the Same as a Pardon
A pardon erases a conviction from an individual’s record. The effect of a pardon by the Governor is that it terminates the punishment and blots out of existence the guilt so that the offender is as innocent as if he had never committed the offense in the eye of the law. Pardons are extraordinary and extremely rare.
Process to Request Petition for Commutation of Sentence
A clemency review may be initiated by an Application for Pardon or a Petition for Commutation of Sentence submitted by a prisoner, someone on their behalf, or their criminal defense attorney. All applications for pardons and commutations must be filed with the Michigan Parole Board and must include the information, records, and documents required by the Michigan Department of Corrections. Section 44 of the Corrections Code describes the Parole Board’s detailed process for considering commutations applications. Ordinarily, the Parole Board must conduct an initial review of the application within 60 days.
Request for Emergency Petition for Commutation of Sentence
It is possible to request emergency consideration from the Governor’s office if a prisoner is medically frail. At the Governor’s request, the parole board will move quickly to review a reprieve, commutation, or pardon based in part on a prisoner’s medical condition. Like a Petition for Commutation of Sentence or a Petition for Clemency, there is no room for error in a request for emergency consideration. There are no second chances. Because a prisoner only gets one shot at this extraordinary relief, it is best to work with a qualified, experienced attorney.
When is a Prisoner Considered Medically Frail?
“Medically frail” describes an individual who is a minimal threat to society as a result of his or her medical condition, who has received a risk score of low on a validated risk assessment, whose recent conduct in prison indicates he or she is unlikely to engage in assaultive behavior, and who has one or both of the following:
- A permanent or terminal physical disability or serious and complex medical condition resulting in the inability to do one or more of the following without personal assistance: walk, stand, or sit, or
- A permanent or terminal disabling mental disorder, including dementia, Alzheimer’s, or a similar degenerative brain disorder resulting in the need for a nursing home level of care and a significantly impaired ability to perform two or more daily living activities.
The Parole Board has the sole statutory duty to transmit its formal recommendation to the Governor regarding the application’s merit. A Petition for Commutation of Sentence based on a medical emergency can be an inmate’s only way to be home with family or get adequate medical treatment.
What happens if a Petition for Executive Clemency is denied?
Have you heard of the expression, “there are no second bites at the apple?” If a Petition for Executive Clemency is denied, a new petition cannot be filed for two years. Because of the emergency nature of the executive clemency process, the Petition must be correct, follow the required procedures, and be exceptionally persuasive. In most cases, it takes a skilled, experienced criminal defense lawyer to give a prisoner their best hope of achieving emergency release from prison.
The only exception to the two-year waiting requirement is a substantial change in circumstances, such as the prisoner’s accelerating deterioration or the progression of a terminal medical condition from which they are not likely to recover.
Parole Board Process
All clemency applications are forwarded to the Parole Board for review. The Parole Board will conduct an initial assessment to determine if there should be a public hearing. If the Parole Board finds that the Petition is without merit, the application is immediately forwarded to the Governor with the Board’s recommendation to deny the application. If the majority of the Parole Board believes there is merit to the Petition for Executive Clemency, the process for consideration commences, and the matter is scheduled for a public hearing.
At the public hearing, the prisoner or petitioner can be questioned on all relevant issues. Members of the public and any victim or victim representative may testify in support of or opposition to the applicant’s clemency.
After the hearing, the case is then referred back to the Board for a final vote on a recommendation to the Governor. After reaching a majority vote, the Parole Board’s recommendation and all relevant materials, including the public hearing transcript and other pertinent documents, are sent to the Governor’s office.
Final Disposition Process
The Governor and their legal staff will review the application and the recommendation of the Parole Board. If the Governor grants the Petition for Commutation, thus reducing the prisoner’s sentence to time served, the Board will vote on parole. If the majority of the 10-member Parole Board is in favor of parole, the board initiates a 28-day notice to the sentencing or successor sentencing judge, prosecutor, and any registered victim. However, in the case of a terminally ill or medically frail prisoner, the Parole Board may seek the prosecutor, judge, and victim consent, to waive the 28-day notice and grant immediate parole release.
Attorneys for Emergency Petition for Commutation of Sentence
The Defense Team with LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. has decades of experience successfully petitioning for extraordinary relief on behalf of its clients. If there is a way to get relief, we will find it. When an incarcerated client of ours is terminally ill or medically frail, we understand that no stone can be left unturned in our zealous advocacy for an Emergency Petition for Commutation of Sentence. Call us if you have a family member or loved one who is severely ill and in need of an emergency release from prison.
Call us today at (248) 263-6800 for a free consultation, or complete a Request for Assistance Form and we will contact you promptly.