Evidence and Rape Kit Testing

Other than homicide cases, more innocent people are convicted of rape than any other offense in Michigan. New rules passed in Michigan will hopefully result in more reliable evidence.

Michigan Criminal Defense Attorneys - Group

Violations of New Forensic Rape Kit Testing Rules Can Result in a Dismissal of Charges

The passage of new requirements for rape kit testing may soon alter the state of Michigan’s criminal sexual misconduct legal landscape. The 2009 discovery of 11,000 untested rape kits in Detroit resulted in changes to the forensic examination rules in Michigan. Police will now be required to obtain a kit from a health center within 14 days of notification and send the kit to a lab for analysis within the following 14 days, after which the lab has an additional 90 days to obtain results.

These changes in rape kit testing rules are to speed up testing for evidence collected in sexual assault cases. There is concern among law enforcement that requiring testing might misdirect limited resources, arguing that often kits are not tested for particular reasons, such as the known identity of a perpetrator. Advocates for the policy change argue that uploading DNA evidence from the kits into state and national databases will nevertheless assist with the investigation of other criminal sexual misconduct cases. Rape kit testing and analysis are often among the most potent tools in sexual assault prosecutions, even though there is a history of false identifications, mishandled evidence, and flawed analysis.

How do top criminal defense lawyers use sloppy police investigations against the prosecution?

Top criminal defense lawyers are adept at turning the tables on the prosecution by meticulously examining the details of police investigations for signs of sloppiness or misconduct. A sloppy police investigation can range from mishandling evidence and failing to follow proper procedures to overlooking potential witnesses. Experienced defense attorneys scrutinize every aspect of the investigation process, looking for inconsistencies, gaps in the evidence, and procedural errors that can undermine the credibility of the prosecution’s case.

One common strategy is to file motions to suppress evidence that was improperly obtained, arguing that it violates the defendant’s constitutional rights. For example, if evidence was collected without a warrant or beyond the scope of a valid warrant, a skilled attorney can argue that such evidence is inadmissible in court. Similarly, if there are inconsistencies in police reports or officers failed to preserve crucial evidence, defense lawyers can use these oversights to question the reliability of the prosecution’s narrative.

Furthermore, top criminal defense lawyers can leverage sloppy police work during cross-examination, highlighting the investigation’s flaws to create reasonable doubt in the minds of jurors. By meticulously dissecting the police procedures and exposing any lack of thoroughness, they can effectively argue that the prosecution has not met its burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

Ultimately, the goal of utilizing these strategies is to protect the rights of the accused and ensure that the justice system functions fairly and accurately. By holding law enforcement accountable for their investigative practices, top criminal defense lawyers like those at LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. play a crucial role in safeguarding the integrity of the legal process and securing the best possible outcomes for their clients.

Attorney - Michigan - Awards

Why is it important to work with lawyers who are knowledgeable about forensic evidence, such as rape kit testing, and scientific defenses?

Working with lawyers who are knowledgeable about forensic evidence, such as rape kit testing, and scientific defenses, is critical in today’s legal landscape, where such evidence often plays a pivotal role in criminal cases. Forensic evidence, including DNA analysis, fingerprinting, ballistics, and digital forensics, can significantly influence the outcome of a trial. Lawyers well-versed in these areas possess the ability to critically examine the methods used to collect, analyze, and interpret forensic data, challenging its validity and reliability when necessary.

Attorneys knowledgeable in scientific defenses can identify potential flaws in the prosecution’s evidence, such as contamination of samples, improper handling or storage, and the limitations of forensic techniques. They are adept at questioning the credentials and methodologies of expert witnesses, potentially discrediting the evidence presented against their clients. This expertise is not only about challenging the prosecution’s case but also about presenting alternative narratives that align with scientific facts, offering a robust defense that can lead to acquittals or reduced charges.

Moreover, an attorney’s understanding of forensic science is crucial for effectively communicating complex scientific information clearly and understandably to judges and juries. This can help demystify technical evidence, making it more accessible and less intimidating, which is essential for a fair evaluation of the facts.

The importance of working with lawyers knowledgeable about forensic evidence and scientific defenses cannot be overstated. It ensures that all evidence is thoroughly scrutinized, upholding the principle that an individual is innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

“Can charges get dismissed if the police make mistakes in their investigation?”

A judge or prosecutor might dismiss felony or misdemeanor charges if the police or law enforcement experts make significant mistakes during their investigation. These mistakes can range from procedural errors to violations of constitutional rights, such as conducting searches without a warrant or failing to read Miranda rights to the accused. Such mistakes can also include errors when collecting or testing rape kits in criminal sexual conduct cases. When law enforcement officials do not adhere to legal standards and protocols, it can undermine the integrity of the evidence collected against the accused.

Defense attorneys play a crucial role in identifying these errors through meticulously reviewing the case details. If a lawyer can demonstrate that critical evidence was obtained unlawfully or that the investigation was conducted in a manner that violates the legal rights of the accused, they can file motions to suppress that evidence. Without the key evidence that was improperly obtained, the prosecution may find their case significantly weakened, sometimes to the point where they have no choice but to dismiss the charges.

Furthermore, a judge may dismiss charges if it is shown that the police mistakes were so substantial that they prevent a fair trial. This could include situations where the law enforcement’s conduct was egregiously wrong, leading to a loss of crucial evidence or irreparably compromising the defendant’s ability to mount a defense.

In both scenarios, the effectiveness of the defense attorney in highlighting these investigative errors is pivotal. With their deep expertise in criminal defense, law firms like LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. are adept at scrutinizing every aspect of the prosecution’s case for such flaws. Their ability to expose mistakes in police investigations not only can lead to the dismissal of charges but also serves to uphold the integrity of the criminal justice system by ensuring that the rights of the accused are protected.

Michigan Criminal Defense Attorney

Michigan Criminal Sexual Conduct Defense Attorneys

The effects of these changes on the criminal justice system in Michigan are yet to be determined. If you, or someone you know, is charged with criminal sexual conduct (CSC), assault with intent to commit criminal sexual conduct or any similar offense, or if you are accused of such a crime, call an experienced, dedicated criminal defense attorney at LEWIS & DICKSTEIN P.L.L.C. We will find a way to help you.

We have decades of experience defending people charged with felony and misdemeanor sexual offenses and all assault charges. When your freedom is at stake, it is crucial that you have the best legal representation available. Call us for a free consultation. We have extensive experience attacking scientific analysis, including rape kit testing, to ensure that any unreliable evidence is exposed.

Call us today at (248) 263-6800 for a free consultation or complete an online Request for Assistance Form. We will contact you promptly and find a way to help you.

We will find a way to help you and, most importantly,
we are not afraid to win!

Contact Us - Michigan Criminal Defense Attorneys